Thursday 18 May 2023 Article

The Takeaway9 Practical Decision-Making Tips for New Managers

How to Overcome the Trials and Tribulations of First-time Management

Part 4

#Tips #HowTo #NewManager #FirstTimeManagementTraining

9 Practical Decision-Making Tips for New Managers

As a first-time manager, you will likely be faced with numerous decisions that can impact your team's success and the overall performance of your organisation. Effective decision-making is a critical skill that will shape your leadership abilities and contribute to achieving your desired outcomes. However, navigating the decision-making process can be challenging without a solid framework. In this article, we will explore practical techniques that can help first-time managers make effective decisions and enhance their decision-making skills.

1. Define Clear Objectives

Before making any decision, it is crucial to define clear objectives by identifying the purpose and desired outcomes of the decision-making process. Clearly articulate what you aim to achieve and consider the potential impact on your team, stakeholders, and the organisation as a whole. Defining clear objectives will provide a guiding framework and ensure that your decisions align with your goals and strategic direction.

2. Gather Relevant Information

Informed decisions are more likely to yield positive results. Collect and analyse relevant information related to the decision at hand. Identify key data, facts, and insights that will enable you to make an informed judgment. Seek input from team members, subject matter experts, and other stakeholders who can provide valuable perspectives. Utilise various sources, such as reports, research, and industry trends, to gather comprehensive information and gain a holistic view of the situation.

3. Evaluate Alternatives

You should always consider multiple alternatives before finalising a decision. Brainstorm and explore various options that could address the problem or opportunity at hand and evaluate the advantages, disadvantages, and potential outcomes associated with each alternative. This process will help you weigh the pros and cons and make a more well-rounded decision. Encourage creativity and diverse perspectives when generating alternatives, as this can lead to innovative solutions and better decision outcomes.


4. Assess Risks and Mitigation Strategies

Every decision involves inherent risks so you should evaluate potential risks and uncertainties associated with each alternative. Identify possible negative consequences and develop mitigation strategies to minimise their impact. Consider both short-term and long-term risks, and assess their likelihood and potential severity. By proactively addressing risks and developing contingency plans, you can make more confident decisions and reduce the chances of unforeseen setbacks.

5. Utilise Decision-Making Models

Decision-making models provide structured frameworks that guide the decision-making process. One commonly used model is the rational decision-making model, which involves systematically evaluating alternatives based on objective criteria. Another popular model is the SWOT analysis, which assesses the strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats associated with each option. You can explore these and other decision-making models to find the one that best suits your decision-making needs and adapt it to your specific situation.

6. Seek Input and Collaboration

As a first-time manager, it is essential to involve your team and stakeholders in the decision-making process. Seek input, perspectives, and expertise from individuals who will be affected by or have valuable insights into the decision. Encourage open dialogue and collaboration, as this not only helps you gather diverse perspectives but also fosters a sense of ownership and engagement among your team members. By involving others, you can leverage the collective intelligence of your team and make more well-rounded decisions.


7. Consider the Long-Term Implications

Effective decision-making involves considering not only immediate outcomes but also the long-term implications of your choices. Evaluate how your decision aligns with the organisation's vision, values, and long-term goals. Anticipate potential ripple effects and assess how the decision may impact various stakeholders and future scenarios. Taking a strategic and forward-thinking approach will help you make decisions that contribute to sustainable growth and success.

8. Implement a Decision-Making Process

Establishing a structured decision-making process can streamline your approach and enhance consistency. Define a step-by-step process that aligns with your organisation's culture and goals. Outline the roles and responsibilities of those involved, set clear timelines, and establish criteria for evaluating alternatives. Implementing a standardised process not only ensures that decisions are made efficiently but also enhances transparency and accountability.

9. Reflect and Learn from Decisions

Every decision provides an opportunity for learning and growth. After making a decision, take the time to reflect on its outcomes and impact. Evaluate the effectiveness of your decision-making process and identify areas for improvement. Acknowledge successes and celebrate achievements, but also be open to learning from any mistakes or challenges encountered. Embrace a continuous improvement mindset and use each decision as a stepping stone to refine your decision-making skills.


Effective decision-making is a vital skill for first-time managers as it directly influences the success of their teams and organisations. With practice and experience, you can become a confident and proficient decision-maker, driving positive outcomes and contributing to your team's growth and success.

Download Our Decision-Making Cheat Sheet here!

First time management can bring many challenges, including decision-making. This quick 1-page cheat sheet summarises 9 tips to help new managers when making decisions.

← View All Daily Dot Posts